Stop the 10-Year Flock Contract: What's Actually in Tuesday's Vote

On Tuesday, Aug. 25, the Monterey County Board of Supervisors will vote on a 10-year, $2.78 million contract to expand license-plate surveillance cameras across the county from 63 to 103, running through August 2036. The public has until Monday at 5:00 PM to weigh in by email and can speak directly to the Board on Tuesday.

This is a decade-long financial and surveillance commitment that the County's own fiscal reviewer has objected to, built on a financing structure designed to work around a budget decision the Board already made. Here's what's actually in it and how to weigh in before it's decided.

The County's own Auditor-Controller objects

The Monterey County Auditor-Controller reviewed this contract and formally stated, in the County's own Board Report, that the office "does not agree to the non-standard payment provisions." That's the County's own fiscal reviewer, on the record, in the official document being submitted to the Board.

Year one is free. Then nine years of payments follow

The Sheriff's Office requested additional funding to continue the Flock program in its regular FY 2026-27 budget. That request was not approved. Flock's response was to offer the County the first year of service at no cost, then bill $309,000 a year for years two through ten, totaling $2,781,000 over the life of the contract.

There's also an early-termination penalty. If the County terminates the agreement before the full ten years, it owes Flock a "chargeback" equal to the value of first-year products and services. That chargeback starts at 100 percent and drops by only 10 percentage points for each completed year, reaching zero only after the full decade. In other words, walking away gets cheaper only by staying in longer.

This is much more than license plate reading

The platform being purchased goes well beyond photographing plates. It includes vehicle location history search, AI-powered search across images and video, custom vehicle watchlists, and the ability to identify vehicles that repeatedly travel together. It can also request access to privately owned Flock cameras at participating businesses, schools, and neighborhoods, extending the practical surveillance footprint well beyond the 103 cameras the County itself owns.

This has already happened once

In 2025, Monterey County Sheriff's Office license plate data was accessible to law enforcement agencies in multiple other states. A Monterey County Weekly public-records investigation surfaced the breach, and Sheriff Tina Nieto confirmed the finding afterward, attributing it to a Flock configuration error that has since been corrected.

That history is exactly why the safeguards in this new agreement matter, and exactly why they deserve more scrutiny than they're currently getting.

The County promises new safeguards. How are they actually enforced?

The Board Report states that Sheriff's Office data will not be shared with federal agencies or law enforcement outside California. That's an important commitment. But the Flock platform itself, as described in the same packet, includes statewide, nationwide, and outside-jurisdiction network capabilities. After a prior configuration failure allowed exactly this kind of unauthorized access, the public deserves clear, public answers: How is that access technically blocked? Who audits it, and how often? What happens if a configuration error happens again? Data retention is set at 30 days, but it's unclear what happens to records that are downloaded, exported, or attached to a case beyond that window.

Why commit for ten years right now?

The County's previous Flock agreement expired on July 25. Flock has continued operating cameras in the county since then without a Board-approved contract in place. Now the Board is being asked to approve a new agreement running through 2036, at the same time the County is developing its own broader standards for data privacy, data sharing, and protection against unauthorized secondary use of county information, a policy process that already received a preliminary staff response on Aug. 11, 2026. A ten-year surveillance contract shouldn't get ahead of the County's own work on exactly this problem.

How to weigh in before Tuesday

Email the Board by Monday, Aug. 24, 5:00 PM. Send your comment to cob@countyofmonterey.gov, with the subject line "Board of Supervisors Agenda Item 9." Ask Supervisors to vote no on Item No. 9, or at minimum to continue the item for fuller public review before committing Monterey County through 2036.

Speak at Tuesday's meeting, roughly 1:30 PM. Join in person at 168 W. Alisal St., 1st Floor, Salinas, or by Zoom. Public comment typically runs about two minutes, at the discretion of the Chair.

Contact your district Supervisor directly. CC them on your email, or call:

For the full action guide, including a sample email, speaking script, and every Supervisor's contact info, click here.

This takes about five minutes if you're just sending the email. If you can make time for either step, it makes a real difference before Tuesday's vote.

Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit
Previous
Previous

PG Progressives' 2026 Endorsements

Next
Next

November 2026 Endorsement Voting